The great crested newt (GCN) is a protected species across the UK, and its conservation largely depends on providing and protecting suitable breeding habitats. Conservationists have long relied on a Habitat Suitability Index (HSI) developed in 2000 to assess the quality of potential breeding habitats for GCNs. However, this index, now over two decades old, was based on limited data and minimal validation. In response, researchers have introduced a new, updated HSI that improves on the accuracy and usability of the original tool for predicting great crested newt presence in UK ponds.
Why a New HSI for Great Crested Newts?
While the original HSI has been widely used to guide great crested newt conservation, its accuracy and ease of use have limitations. Recognizing these issues, researchers sought to create a more effective tool that would make conservation planning and habitat management for GCNs simpler and more reliable. The new HSI is specifically designed to better predict where GCNs are likely to be found, allowing for more targeted conservation actions that can make a real difference for this endangered species.
Key Improvements in the New Great Crested Newt HSI
The updated Habitat Suitability Index introduces several changes that make it both easier to use and more accurate. Here’s what makes it stand out:
- Simplified Calculations
The new HSI uses an arithmetic mean instead of the previous geometric mean to combine variables. This change reduces calculation errors and allows compensation between variables, making it more user-friendly for those assessing GCN habitats. - Revised Environmental Factors
Extensive testing and feedback indicated that some variables in the old HSI, like water quality and waterfowl impact, did not accurately predict GCN presence. These variables have been removed from the new index, making it simpler without compromising effectiveness. - Updated Scoring System
The scoring system for pond area was revised to better reflect current data and now provides scores for ponds over 2,000 m², making it more inclusive of larger water bodies that may also serve as GCN habitats. - Improved Graphs and Calculations
Modifications to pond density score calculations have also been implemented, providing users with clear and precise tools to reduce errors and enhance prediction reliability.
Developing the New HSI: A Data-Driven Approach
To develop the new HSI, researchers used a two-pronged approach to ensure its relevance and reliability:
- User Survey
A survey was conducted with 288 users of the old HSI to understand its strengths and limitations. This feedback was essential in identifying the most effective and least useful elements of the existing index. - National Data Analysis
Using large datasets on GCN presence/absence and environmental variables, researchers analyzed various factors to determine the relative importance of each in predicting GCN presence. This data-driven approach allowed for the exclusion of weaker variables and the refinement of scoring systems for the most influential factors.
Testing the New Index for Reliability
To validate the new index, researchers compared it against the original HSI using an independent dataset. The results were promising: the new HSI demonstrated a stronger relationship between habitat suitability and GCN presence, with larger effect sizes and higher R-squared values. This improvement in accuracy means conservationists and land managers can have greater confidence in habitat assessments, leading to better-informed decision-making for great crested newt protection.
What Does This Mean for Great Crested Newt Conservation?
The adoption of this updated HSI is a positive step for the future of great crested newt conservation. With a more reliable tool to assess habitat suitability, conservationists and environmental professionals can make smarter, more efficient decisions about protecting GCN habitats. This, in turn, supports the continued survival of this iconic species in the UK and ensures that conservation efforts are both effective and sustainable.
Conclusion: The Future of Great Crested Newt Conservation
With the introduction of the new HSI, conservationists have a powerful, data-backed tool to better protect great crested newts. By making the assessment process simpler and more accurate, this new index allows for more precise habitat management and enables conservation teams to focus efforts where they will have the greatest impact. For everyone involved in great crested newt conservation, this updated HSI offers a hopeful path forward, paving the way for enhanced protection of one of the UK’s most treasured species.
If you require great crested newt surveys on your project please get in touch on 02920 650 331 or contact us at enquiries@acerecology.co.uk
The full paper is available here
